|
Burbank Water and Power
BUSINESS PLAN FOR COMMUNICATION SERVICES AS A UTILITY SERVICE OF
Burbank Water and Power
10/19/94
TABLE OF CONTENTS
- EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
- GENERAL DESCRIPTION OF Burbank Water and
Power FIBER OPTIC COMMUNICATION SYSTEM
- THE MARKET FOR FIBER OPTIC COMMUNICATIONS
- Local Area Network (LAN) Integration
- Video Transmission Capability
- Dark Fiber
- Post Production Review and Control
- Telephone PBX Interconnect
- Future Markets
- THE FIBER OPTIC SYSTEM PLAN
- STRATEGIC ANALYSIS AND CONSIDERATIONS
- FINANCIAL PROJECTS FOR BWP FIBER
OPTIC SYSTEM
- SALES FORECAST
- CAPITAL REQUIREMENTS AND
ANNUALIZED EXPENSES
- OPERATING RESULTS
- IMPLEMENTATION OF COMMUNICATION SERVICES
EXECUTIVE
SUMMARY
Fiber Optic communication technologies are revolutionizing the
communications industry because of their high performances and low
costs. In addition to their performance and cost advantages, fiber
optics are not affected by electric voltages or currents. Its immunity
to electricity makes fiber optics an attractive communication technology
for an electric utility such as Burbank Water and Power. The communication
system (copper wire) currently used to monitor and control Burbank
Water and Power facilities can be subject to failure during electrical
disturbances because of its conductive nature.
Power utilities throughout the country have and are installing
fiber optic communications to control, monitor, and operate their
power systems. Los Angeles Department of Water and Power, Southern
California Edison, and Pacific Gas and Electric as well as local
municipal utilities have begun to install fiber optics. For example,
the City of Anaheim has just begun a planned three year construction
program to build an extensive fiber optic system for its municipal
utility and other city services.
These power utility fiber optic applications have been justified
on the basis of improved communications for the control of the electric
utility and other City or utility uses. Reduction in costs of fiber
and fiber equipment has made fiber optics less expensive over the
years now making it a cost effective technology for utilities, such
as ours.
In August 1992, then Vice Mayor, George Battey asked if it might
be possible for Burbank Water and Power to make communications services
available to others. The timing of this inquiry proved most fortunate.
Changes in communication technology and regulation have made the
concept of constructing a public fiber optic network feasible. Further,
Burbank's entertainment companies need for such systems are rapidly
growing as digital technology becomes the typical form for film
and video production. A public network that would be locally controlled
and thus able to quickly meet specific needs of our customers would
be very desirable for these customers.
The City in conjunction with Sammons Cable Systems is developing
a video with data network called I-net that will link governmental
and school units in each of the two cities. The I-net system fiber
optic requirements are proposed to be provided by both Sammons and
Burbank Water and Power. By operating this Sammons fiber facility
in conjunction with Burbank Water and Power system a wider area,
more powerful, network with other capabilities may be constructed
at a low cost. This development will be part of the Sammon's franchise
agreement with the City of Burbank.
It has taken a year and a half to review and consider the market
for this technology. We have found that fiber optic cable is the
cornerstone of this technology. It is a relatively stable technology
that is well suited for utility applications and also capable of
providing the types of services desired by the entertainment element
of our business community.
Our plan calls for us to build an initial fiber system, with some
networking, operating at high speeds. This requires the installation
of fiber optic cables and electronic devices to convert the electrical
signal to light and back to electrical signals at the receiving
sites. Building on this base, as the applications improve and customer
usage increase over time, will allow us to take advantage of maturing
technologies early in their application.
This plan does not provide for commercial cable television applications,
however, such applications may be considered and accommodated in
the future when digital technologies are more widely used for such
applications. Our plan takes advantage of our existing management
structure and capabilities of our current personnel. Our marketing
representation will require strengthening in the second year. Technical
design and project management skills may also be needed. However,
we may begin now with little change in existing staffing levels.
This plan calls for us to provide retail communication services.
The Burbank City Charter allows broad definition of utility services,
beyond water and power, including any utility service. Communication
technology no longer requires a monopoly utility service. Fiber
optic network will help improve communication technology where available.
We would provide this service at cost, without long term subsidies
by electric customers.
It is the intent of this plan to provide a broad range of communication
services and attract new service and service providers, starting
with the simpler applications and expanding into the more complex.
The plan calls for us to work with other communication companies
to provide services in a cost efficient manner. Such companies as
Pacific Bell, and new phone companies such as Teleport and Metropolitan
Fiber System, specialized service providers, and the City can both
compete and cooperate in bringing modern communication services
to the City at a competitive price. We have developed a cooperative
arrangement with Teleport that is an example of how we can work
with other systems.
The system will be constructed over time. Initial coverage is designed
to provide services to our electrical facilities. This will allow
the linkage of the media district, the airport, and downtown.
Future loops will be constructed as needed and feasible. City-wide
communication services have not been considered at this time. However,
no applications have been identified, future applications may identify
such needs, and technology will likely reduce costs thus making
the likelihood of a city-wide network possible in the future.
Constructing a communication system with sufficient capacity to
meet the needs of the utility and others require larger capability
than we would construct for our own needs, however, building the
initial system at the larger capacity increases the cost by less
than $50,000. Other municipal utilities have each recently installed
fiber optic systems solely for their own needs. They now wish they
would have spent the little extra required for a larger system.
In order to add this capacity after construction they would duplicate
many expenses. It is far less expensive to build surplus capacity
into a new system than to add capacity to an existing system.
This business plan shows that constructing a municipal fiber optic
communication system simply for telephone services would be a marginal
and risky venture. In order to be a prudent undertaking a need such
as monitoring and controlling an electric utility operation must
exist. It is doubtful that municipalities who do not have electric
operations would find our plan attractive.
The key elements of this plan are the following:
- Construct a fiber optic communication system which can control
and monitor the electrical facilities of Burbank Water and Power
during electrical disturbances with little risk of failure.
- Construct sufficient capacity in the fiber optic communication
system to accommodate future needs of the utility and the community
including portions of I-Net for the City of Burbank and Burbank
Unified School District.
- Provide specialized communication services at a rate sufficient
to generate revenues to pay for the system without long term subsidies
by electric or water customers.
- Provide communication facilities for a fee to communication
companies and communication services providers to encourage a
competitive market for communication services that enhances the
desirability of Burbank for communication dependent businesses.
With the consent of the City Council, Burbank Water and Power will
begin the construction and operation of the proposed communication
system.
The following activities will be required:
- Parties who have expressed interest in services that could be
included in the initial construction phase will be contacted and
their requirements incorporated and included in the construction
plan as required.
- The City Attorney will review any regulatory or legal considerations
associated with providing services to others.
- Any significant service contract or agreement for construction
of this system will be brought to the City Council for its approval.
- Any rates and regulations for services will be brought to the
City Council for its approval.
The initial system will be funded by Burbank Water and Power and
will be constructed over a twelve month period at an initial system
cost of $915,000. It will be managed as its own cost center, so
that the cost of contracting and maintaining the system can be "billed"
to its utility and non-utility users.
GENERAL DESCRIPTION
OF BURBANK WATER AND POWER FIBER OPTIC COMMUNICATION SYSTEM
The fiber optic communication system is needed to provide a communication
network that will be immune to electrical faults and be capable
of carrying a large variety of communication traffic required to
safely and efficiently operate Burbank Water and Power (BWP) utility
services. In addition, the system shall provide communication services
for the community that will retain and attract new businesses and
business lines. The system will be developed over time as required
and feasible so that all City facilities, and our residents, will
have access to our system and communication services from others
throughout the City.
Burbank Water and Power's current communication system consists
of copper wires with some limited fiber optic applications. The
fiber optic applications were first installed in 1987 for the purpose
of linking Burbank Water and Power to the City Hall and its computer
system. Fiber optics are also used to monitor and control the City's
microwave system from BWP's communication shop and to extend a local
area network.
The copper communication system is extensive and is used for specialized
telephone, data, control and electrical system protection device
applications. The copper communication system has experienced problems
during severe electrical outages. Often, large electrical currents
and voltage fluctuations are present when an electrical outage occurs.
These currents and voltage fluctuations can cause the loss of communications
at a time that such service is important to restore electrical power.
Burbank Water and Power has taken the measures necessary to reduce
these undesired effects, however, they cannot be totally eliminated
from a copper communication system. Communication companies, such
as Pacific Bell, are aware of these problems and simply refuse to
bring their copper communication lines directly into an electrical
power facility.
Fiber optic communication systems are generally unaffected by electrical
disturbances. The fibers do not conduct electricity and the electronic
devices connected to the fibers may be battery powered, and thus
isolated from the electrical power grid. Many electric utilities
are implementing fiber optic systems which provide better control
and protection of their power systems than copper may provide. Southern
California Edison Company, for example, has a large fiber network
in operation for its utility.
It will take time, experience, and resources of the BWP in order
to replace and improve our communication system with a fiber system.
Our objectives can be staged so that we can gain experience as the
system grows and better control our use of BWP resources.
Technology improvements are reducing the cost of fiber optic terminal
equipment regularly. By staging our implementation over time, we
may take advantage of these cost reductions in the future.
Our first objectives will be the following:
- Connect the fiber optic communication system (System) to major
electrical facilities.
- Construct an initial loop of the System so that it is near significant
early users of the system including City and school facilities
for I-net applications.
- Develop interconnections with regional communication companies
to provide the effective and desirable communication capabilities
for our users by making a significant market available to them
without duplicating an extensive fiber system within Burbank.
The first loop will connect our major electrical facilities. These
facilities include our offices, SCADA center, switching stations,
power plants and seven distributing stations.
This first loop passes near City facilities, the major studios,
a major medical facility, numerous production companies, large office
complexes and many City facilities. The final route may be adjusted
or expanded as required to meet the needs of others that are not
now included.
We recognize that it is important to be able to provide broadband
communications beyond the boundaries of Burbank. We have opened
discussions for such interconnections with others such as AT&T,
Pacific Bell, Teleport Communications Group and Los Angeles Department
of Water and Power. Each of these parties have unique strengths
and weaknesses. Others, such as Sprint, MCI, Metropolitan Fiber
Systems, Sammons Communication Systems and Southern California Edison
are also possible carriers.
Pacific Bell has shown support for interconnection with our System.
Its initial Information Super Highway development will not travel
directly through Burbank, but Pacific Bell does have an existing
fiber optic communication system in Burbank that may possibly connect
to our system and by 1996 made part of their statewide Information
Super Highway. Its system and our system can enhance one another.
These combined facilities will ensure an abundance of fiber from
more than one provider of services, creating a competitive environment.
Los Angeles Department of Water and Power has a fiber optic system
which extends into Burbank near the Media District and also has
terminations at its Toluca Receiving Station, our electrical interconnection
point for outside power imports. It has a capacity that could be
used to reach downtown Los Angeles and the West Los Angeles areas.
Our long term objectives are:
- Secure a very reliable two-way communication path to effectively
and economically control and monitor our electrical facilities
and load. Provide City I-net services in conjunction with Sammons
or others in an economical manner.
- Continually improve our communication services to maintain excellent,
high quality state of the art service.
- Interconnect with other communication providers and/or users
to provide low cost, effective long distance communication services.
We will first approach these objectives by providing communication
services using simple fiber optic strands connected between points.
These strands will be strung in 96 strand cables that will be installed
in our existing overhead and underground electrical facilities.
We may also provide communication services from digital communication
hubs which will allow for greater reliability and better use of
cable resources.
By using our existing underground and electrical facilities we
may install fiber optic cables easily and at a much lower cost than
if we were required to install new poles or underground conduits.
For example, the most basic of underground conduit for communication
service costs approximately $20 per foot, plus the cost of the cable
($4 to $8 per foot installed). By using our existing facilities
we can build our system for less than half the cost that it would
cost others. Sammons could build at a cost comparable to us but
they are limited in the services that they may provide.
Wholesale marketing of communication services will be an important
marketing channel. This channel would provide communication services
to such communication retail companies as Pacific Bell, Teleport
Communication Group, or Los Angeles Cellular. Reseller marketers
of a specialized service may be important wholesale customers of
our system. For example, a firm providing specialized high resolution,
low distortion video feeds for professional level applications could
use our system to make this service available in our service area.
Some retail marketing is feasible. Examples of specific market
segments for direct sales to end users are the studios and post
production companies. The entertainment industry is rapidly using
digital methods for producing video and composing film and special
effects.
We have discussed these services with Disney, Warner Bros., NBC
and several post production companies and have found specific needs
where we could be of assistance. Smaller production companies have
expressed interest in cost effective solutions, but details have
not been discussed sufficiently to determine such solutions.
We would fold these services into our electric business line, much
like we have combined the reclaimed water program with our water
supply services. As these services become significant we would form
a separate division for its operation. There would always be some
overlap as communications are vital to power system control. Operation
and communication lines would be initially constructed and maintained
by our electric field personnel, however utility communications
and applications could be a separate division.
Project management would be provided by Ron Stassi, General Manager
of BWP; Fred Fletcher, Power System Manager; Greg Simay, Electrical
Services Manager; Sam Mahsoul, Senior Electrical Engineer; Chuck
Beller, Supervising Electrical Engineer; John Cassidy, and Jerry
Recker Electric Services Engineers; Richard Andersen, Electrical
Test Coordinator; Chuck Herron, Electric Distribution Supervisor
and Hanes Isaacs, Electric Shop Supervisor.
Ron Stassi who is the Department Head would oversee the operation
and provide general management and oversight as he does for other
BWP activities in Burbank Water and Power's operation. Fred Fletcher
would direct the business line, Greg Simay would direct construction.
Sam Mahsoul would coordinate the technical design and review the
construction. Chuck Beller would assist Sam and integrate the fiber
system into our electric utility operations. John Cassidy and Jerry
Recker would design the fiber optic lines and feeders. Chuck Herron
would supervise the crews that construct the fiber optic lines and
feeders. Hanes Isaacs would supervise the crews that terminate,
secure and maintain the fiber optic station end points. Richard
Andersen supervise those who would test the lines, maintain switching
devices and make connections with customer equipment.
In addition to this management team, two additional positions may
be required as the enterprise grows. These positions are a communications
engineer and communications account representative. The communications
engineer would be responsible for the technical operation of our
communication system and the interconnection agreements with other
communication companies and resellers. He would be familiar with
digital networks and be able to resolve problems with such systems.
The communications account representative would be responsible for
the implementation of our marketing plans and addressing customer
concerns. This employee would implement marketing efforts in conjunction
with our agreements with other communication companies and resellers.
THE MARKET FOR
FIBER OPTIC COMMUNICATIONS
The market for fiber optic communication services is broad and
developing rapidly. Prices for fiber optic technology are in decline
and the availability of fiber for long distance communication is
rapidly growing.
Because of the large percentage of entertainment industry companies
in Burbank and because these companies are located relatively close
to one another, we have focused on this market group. Fiber optics
is well suited for digital applications. The entertainment industry
has recently begun to use digital technology in an extensive manner.
Digital video and film application are rapidly replacing traditional
methods. For this reason fiber optics is well suited to interconnect
the production facilities of this industry.
Burbank has large, small, and medium sized entertainment companies.
Determining their needs can be difficult. Some are very knowledgeable
of technology, others are not. Some find interconnection with other
companies to be very important to their growth while a few do not
see such interconnections to be an advantage. Many of these firms
are most interested in producing high quality profitable media products
and view communications as an outside service in order to not detract
them from their primary business. Determining their needs can be
difficult if not impossible.
We held a fiber optic exposition in Burbank at our Administration
Building to identify some of the interest in fiber optics in the
entertainment industry. Attendance was excellent, over 120 entertainment
managers and technicians attended the event. We gave little advance
notice and provided a unique demonstration so as to attract those
who can act with some speed and recognize a unique application of
technology when presented.
Contacts developed at this show have been used to understand the
significant market segments in the entertainment industry. We found
the following applications to be important to the market in Burbank.
They have been ranked according to estimated market size.
- Local Area Network (LAN) Integration.
- Video Transmission Capability.
- Dark Fiber.
- Production Review and Control.
- Telephone PBX interconnections.
These services would use well developed technologies and have low
technical risks associated with their implementation. Services requiring
specialized technology would be provided by others willing to provide
and maintain the specialized equipment. We would simply sell communication
services to such providers of such specialized technology.
A. Local Area Network (LAN) Integration
The studios have several local area networks (LAN) throughout their
properties and have the need to interconnect them. They have some
interest in the ability to interconnect with LAN's of other companies
from time to time for specific reasons and applications.
Local area networks can be connected with simple LAN fiber optic
repeaters. A more versatile approach would be using a router or
bridge to connect LAN's as required. In the longer term, more advanced
network switching methods could be used. We will first implement
this service using simply fiber optic cable and later, after we
have greater experience with more complex connections, provide progressively
more sophisticated connections.
We have experience in interconnection of computer systems using
fiber repeaters. The service is very reliable, fast and simple to
implement. Linking LAN'S with two strands of fiber is simple. It
does, however, require the exclusive use of the fiber with which
it is connected.
Multiple Local Area Network interconnections over a single pair
of fiber strands is proposed under the Asynchronous Transfer Mode
(ATM) standards being developed by the telecommunication industry.
However, these standards are not yet complete. Initial LAN interconnections
would be done by dedicated fiber and later transferred to ATM hubs
when available.
B. Video Transmission Capability
Video transmission capability is a surprisingly vague term. The entertainment
industry has very strict and high standards for production level video
transmission. Even standards under development are not capable of
delivering the quality required by some in the entertainment production
industry. There are proprietary methods that will provide video transmission
and switching as defined by the Society of Motion Picture and Television
Engineer Standard 601.
Because of the technical nature and need for specific market knowledge
regarding this application, a reseller approach to this market segment
should be developed. Choosing the most effective proprietary system
is difficult for the best. A reseller approach to this market segment
would transfer the technology applications risk and customer contact
to a reseller.
Our initial approach to this market is to provide fiber optic interconnections
and deploy more advanced connections later after we have gained
experience. Fortunately, our community has many firms quite capable
of connecting their own video equipment to our fiber optic strands
that we would lease. Video can, however, be sent over fiber using
compression with good results. Compressed video in what the industry
refers to as DS-3 (about 45 million bits per second) and DS-1 (about
1.5 million bits per second) channels is very practical from both
wholesale and retail standpoints. The Wiltel Company product group
called Vyvx provides such services nationwide and is available in
Burbank. We could provide services to Vyvx on a wholesale basis,
thus making Vyvx services more widely available in Burbank. We could
also provide DS-3 or DS-1 interconnects within Burbank for local
video communications.
Local video services would be useful for security reasons. Firms
could use the fiber to monitor remote locators in Burbank via fiber.
In conjunction with Sammon's Cable TV franchise and I-net network
capabilities it may be possible to offer analog video communication
services. This application is possible under this business plan
but the preliminary engineering associated with its design has not
yet begun.
C. Dark Fiber Dark Fiber is
simply fiber optic fibers connecting two points. The customer is responsible
for applying their own signaling in the fiber. This allows the customer
broad applications and greater control over such signaling. The downside
of a dark fiber installation is that its only available point to point
and can only be manually switched or configured.
Dark Fiber service is not well suited for general service as it
may not be available at many locations and length limitations may
make it unfeasible. But for many applications with relative short
spans near our fiber loops, Dark Fiber service would possibly be
a viable option.
Dark Fiber service would be an excellent choice for a large company
with multiple buildings requiring many types of services. The company
could secure Dark Fibers to construct their own fiber network and
run their own networks.
The City could use Dark Fiber to support its share of the "Smart
Highway" program or to interconnect its offices. Disney, Warner
Brothers, or other companies with multiple locations throughout
the City may also wish to use the Dark Fiber service.
Dark Fiber service is the simplest and easiest service that we
will be able to offer to potential subscribers.
D. Post-Production Review and Control
Post-production review and control is an entertainment industry practice
that allows for post-production jobs performed remotely to be reviewed
as work in progress.
For example, a television station may wish to have an outside firm
create a 10 second promo for a late night show that uses footage
recently taped from the show. The footage would be physically sent
to the production company who would then compile the promo. The
producer of the show could review the drafts of the promo over the
fiber system and make any recommendation. When the promo meets with
the producer's approval, it would be finalized and immediately physically
shipped to the station for use. This process speeds final production,
but the tape must be physically transferred to the post-production
house and back to the company.
Approval Quality review is a low cost video link from the output
of a video editing machine to another location. The quality is sufficient
for the producer's review. The quality is not sufficient for broadcast.
A broadcast quality video link would be more expensive that an Approval
Quality Link.
This application has become very popular with many firms offering
specialized gear for this application. We will provide the fiber
optic interconnections between these specialized devices that our
customers have secured. As we gain more experience we may offer
more advanced methods to interconnect this equipment.
E. Telephone PBX Interconnect
Growing companies require larger facilities. It is often less expensive
to simply lease office space nearby for the incremented growth than
to relocate the entire operation. However, leasing separate office
space often isolates the new office from the existing office.
The customer's telephone PBX equipment must have fiber optic ports
in order for us to link their equipment. A review of PBX vendors
and some of our potential customers found that such ports are available.
We would simply link these devices with fiber optic cables. Later,
for added reliability and better use of fibers we would integrate
these applications with a network. By linking office phone systems,
common local office phone switch intercoms, inter-office numbering
schemes and uniform phone features can be maintained. It can also
provide a single point of control for telecommunication services.
This market segment is a retail market that is important to some
of our potential customers. By providing this service, we help the
customers and provide them better service. It is a service we will
use in our utility operation in the form of our substation phone
system that is referred to as "country phone" by our BWP
personnel.
Future Markets The development
of low cost fiber optic technology and broadband communication technology
will expand the application for fiber optic communication services.
By developing our system in a manner consistent with this development
we can take advantage of the growing market. Fortunately, this market
requires interconnections between companies and vendors, thus assuring
technology that is well defined and available for our use. The differentiation
of firms and services will be in the applications, features and price
of their service. Our role is to help facilitate these applications
in Burbank by using generally applied technology.
THE FIBER
OPTIC SYSTEM PLAN
Fiber optic cables are usually composed of fiber optic strands
arranged in even multiples of six. Fiber optic strands are primarily
classed as either single-mode or multi-mode. The strands may be
further classed according to the glass formation and the subsequent
cladding (protective cover) process. Some strands are best for digital
signals, others are best for analog signals. Single-mode or multi-mode
designations are very specific classes and are not compatible. Digital
fiber and analog fiber may be interchanged but will experience some
loss of performance.
Our system would be primarily composed of 96 strand single-mode
fiber cables. Ninety-six strands will allow us to link applications
point to point simply using fibers. Other municipal systems have
used 24 or 48 strands only to find considerably less capacity for
system growth than they foresaw. The larger fiber counts are needed
to distribute the fiber signals to other points and facilities as
needs arise.
The cable would first be strung along our existing pole lines and
in underground conduits. The initial route would link the Ralph
Foy Park area, the Media District, and the Downtown area in a loop
configuration. This initial loop would connect our Valley, Lincoln
and Olive Switching Stations, Golden State, Hollywood Way and San
Jose, Burbank, Town, Alameda and Naomi Distributing Stations, BWP
Administration, Olive Power Plant, Magnolia Power Plant, City Hall,
the SCADA Center and Los Angeles Department of Water and Power Toluca
Receiving Station (our point of electrical power interconnection
for outside power).
The McCambridge, Victory and Flower Distributing Stations would
be connected to the system after the initial loop is completed.
Customer stations will also be considered and installed as appropriate,
depending upon our requirement.
Our line distribution personnel have successfully installed fiber
optic cables in the past. The oldest application is the fiber link
from BWP to City Hall. This application has been in operation for
over seven years and has been literally trouble free. Two years
ago we installed fiber lines to monitor and control the City's microwave
system. The most recently constructed fiber system links were Water
Division's Control Stations. Our field crews are familiar with fiber
optic cable handling, termination, set up, and trouble shooting.
The handling requirements are no more strict than the strict handling
requirements of high voltage underground cables.
Each segment of the loop would terminate in a Burbank Water and
Power or City facility onto a panel that will allow optical termination
of each strand of fiber. These panels will allow the strands to
be connected in a variety of ways to form the communication network.
Located at these termination points will be specialized fiber optic
switching devices called repeaters, hubs, or cross connects which
route lines and communication paths as required.
Repeaters are the most simple devices. They cost a few hundred
dollars to a couple of thousand dollars. They are specialized devices
that transfer a certain kind of signal across a fiber optic strand.
These devices are typically used to extend or link local area networks.
Hubs are multi-port devices that connect several devices to fiber
strands. Hubs may link many terminals to a mainframe computer. Burbank
Water and Power computer terminals are connected to the City's computer
over a hub.
Hubs might also act as bridges or routers. Bridges and routers
allow for a connection between computer networks or systems. Some
of these devices are quite fast and able to connect a large number
of network users. Others are low cost, simple systems allowing different
network or devices to communicate.
Under development are Asynchronous Transfer Mode (ATM) hubs that
will allow a low-cost connection of networks at a very high speed.
These hubs are expected to be very useful and widely used. There
are new devices with fewer than 500 in service. Once these devices
have been proven, they may have use in our system.
Hubs vary greatly in price. Simple hubs might cost only $1500 to
$2500 in the form of bridges. Router hubs cost between $2000 and
$10,000. ATM hubs cost between $10,000 and $80,000.
Cross connect equipment connect fiber lines and communication paths
as required. Such devices are called SONET hubs and digital cross
connects. SONET hubs are capable of rerouting communication paths
or lines in the event of failure and allow for fast multi-use applications.
Digital cross connects connect fiber lines to one another as required.
Cross connects and SONET hubs cost as little as $25,000 for simple
terminals to a few million dollars for complex systems used to drive
transoceanic fiber networks. For our applications, these devices
would cost between $25,000 and $90,000.
Costs are declining for these devices priced at the high end. The
low end of the market is increasing in performance rather than in
the lowering of price.
Our electric power system control and protection should be secure
and capable of withstanding single line or equipment failure or
removed from the system for maintenance, testing, or upgrade. This
application is best met by a SONET network. Such a network would
require at least three nodes. These nodes would likely be at Valley
Station, Hollywood Way Distributing Station and the BWP yard.
At least one DS-1 (1.5 million bits per second) channel will be
available to each facility from the SONET network. The DS-1 channel
at a facility would be divided into 24 DS-0 (64,000 bits per second)
lines. This will allow control, protection, monitoring and voice
communication for each facility. The DS-1 would be modified from
the Bellcore Standard so it would be switched much faster then other
DS-1's in the event of a loss of signal. This modification is required
for power system operation.
In the future, the use of local area network repeaters, simple
fiber strands, SONET terminals and multiplexers may permit us to
provide the communication needs for the electric utility and the
specific markets we have identified.
ATM communication technology may be available in less than two
years and will allow switching of the broadband channels. This will
open new application and markets. ATM is best deployed on OC-48
and higher SONET networks. For this reason most broadband community
and regional information networks are operated at OC-48 levels.
The "OC-48" designation refers to a speed of 2600 million
bits per second, a speed faster than virtually any single computer.
Operation at OC-48 is clearly the best technical path, but it costs
more than OC-12. Operation at OC-12 initially, upgrading to OC-48
in two years and redeploying the OC-12 equipment in neighborhood
loops is a sequencing plan that is likely to lower our costs. Interconnection
at OC-48 with other companies allows for more reliable and less
costly interoperability. Specific operation level determination
is not practical at this time. Budget estimates are based on the
less expensive OC-12 level.
Operation of other specialized networks or applications within
our fiber system is practical. For example, Sammons, the current
cable TV operator, may want to integrate its needs into our system.
In order to do so, we might lease it fiber strands that meet its
requirements for facilities which are installed and maintained in
our right-of-way. In a similar manner, we might lease fiber strands
to Disney and Warner Bros. for private networks for their individual
operations. Operations between the various private networks, the
utility system, and the City's I-net system may also be made possible
as desired.
STRATEGIC
ANALYSIS AND CONSIDERATIONS
The purpose of strategic analysis and consideration is to examine
the opportunities, objectives and capabilities of the business plan
in a synergistic manner. This approach will use some management
concepts and business development models to frame the business plan
in a strategic manner.
Prior discussion has outlined the objectives, market, and technical
considerations. This section will consider the fit of these elements
in conjunction with Burbank Water and Power and refine the business
plan to augment our strengths and avoid our weaknesses.
Using a model developed by McKinsey & Company, we will now
consider those the factors defined by McKinsey & Company to
be attributes of good organizational strategies of well run companies
as they relate to this proposal. These firms relied on simple organizational
structures, strategies and goals. They had the following characteristics:
- A bias towards action.
- A simple organization structure and lean staff.
- Continued contact with customer.
- Productivity improvement from within the organization.
- Operational control and entrepreneurship at the lowest levels.
- ONE key business value.
- Emphasizing doing what the firm knows best.
- Focused yet loose controls.
A Bias Towards Action
Successful organizations have a bias towards action in specific
areas. However, such action must be directed toward the strategic
objective of the business line. Burbank Water and Power has a bias
towards action in the establishment of electric service and the
return of electric service in the event of outage.
The establishment of electric service is done in a direct manner,
using a minimum of paperwork, by employees who do several such jobs
each month. It is an operation done primarily by those directly
involved with the process. Improvements in electric service technology
are made in an orderly manner by those directly involved with the
evaluation and implementation of the improvement. Management reviews
to ensure customers are being well served.
Outages are handled by those performing the work. Paperwork is
very minimal and done after the work is complete. Outage review
is conducted by field supervisors and engineering. Concerns are
for fast, reliable and safe repair and restoration of service.
Our strategic implementation for this business line and service
should be based on the speed and methodology used for the establishment
and restoration of electric service.
A Simple Organization Structure and Lean
Staff
A business unit requires different approaches and structures in
order to meet the different problems associated with the phases
a business experiences as it develops. The initial organizational
structure calls for an entrepreneurial structure. As the technical
and marketing functions develop, a need for functional organization
occurs and the entrepreneurial structure becomes too restrictive
and slow. Then, as the business develops a variety of distinct and
separate products or services, it develops a need for a divisional
organizational structure. A divisional structure might consist of
a division manager directing fiber communication, local area networks,
commercial networks or other service.
Our strategic approach, in order to assure a simple and lean organization,
is to implement an evolving structure that is prepared to change
its form as it grows.
Our initial structure will use the entrepreneurial structure using
existing staff. This initial staff should include provisions to
secure a professional technical employee and a marketing or customer
relations employee. As the technical and marketing needs develop,
the technical and marketing roles will become functions led by a
technical section manager and a marketing section manager.
If other separate services develop or if other services are assigned
to this group, a divisional structure may be developed. The separate
services of the division should be relatively the same size.
A uniform accounting system should be used throughout BWP. Using
a variety of accounting systems makes it difficult to utilize accounting
methods to monitor the utility's performance or effectiveness.
We should use existing field personnel under the current organizational
structure and deviate from it only when it is an effective measure
in terms of customer service and price. If it is possible to use
our current electric service designers to perform communication
related service drops we should do so, if practical. However, because
of work load outside contractors may be required.
Our strategic implementation of this business line in terms of
organization is to establish an initial organization using current
budget positions with provisions for a communication engineer and
a communication customer support representative. We will keep the
organization as simple as possible by using common accounting methods.
Continued Contact With Customer
Upon identification of our market segment interest we compiled listings
of customer and specific individuals within those companies who
are responsible for using communication services. We held a fiber
optic technology exposition which further helped us identify individuals
and their interests.
An informal network has been formed to facilitate communication
with potential customers. Linkage among the interest group will
be arranged on the Internet, a widely used computer and e-mail network.
The informal group's role is to provide Burbank Water and Power
input and provide a forum for application development and deployment.
The larger studios in town have identified needs and application
that require multiple addresses throughout the City. Other Media
District companies are considering expanding their offices to other
locations in Burbank which would require a reliable large capacity
communication between various points. This informal group serves
as a method to address these needs both as a group and individually.
These groups provide the necessary input and close working relationship
with our customers that is so important to all of us.
Productivity Improvements From Within
the Organization
Productivity is improved in communication services by the following:
- Expanded availability of service points.
- Lower prices, or cost per unit of service.
- Improved applications.
- Redevelopment of switching capability.
- Multiple use of facilities and channels.
All of the above factors are to some degree dependent upon internal
development. Availability of service points and prices can be managed
and developed internally. Improved applications come from working
with application developers and our customers.
Switching capability allows customers to be interconnected with
one another, much like the phone system. Its availability is dependent
on the development of the standards for this service and then the
hardware. Still, even without the standards and hardware, switching
capability could be developed using video switching equipment, fiber
line switching or operator arrested communication path switching.
This productivity improvement is an important element for many applications
and therefore is an important development for many applications
and companies.
The key to low price and improved application is multiple use of
facilities. Our staff will have to work to ensure facilities are
used to their fullest extent. Early users should be capable of being
transferred to multiple use technologies at a later date as technology
develops.
All of these factors are improvements to be made by our organization.
We can not rely on others to show us how our system might use technologies
and applications. It is therefore important that our organization
take advantage of the experience and knowledge of our employees
familiar with cables, underground facilities, customer facilities
and joint pole usage. We must also take advantage of the experience
and development of our customers who have expertise in communications.
ONE Key Business Value
Price is important, but in developing markets price is a hygiene
factor, too high a price will reduce market share, but low prices
may not increase market share unless the application is developed
and fiber simply improves its feasibility. The important factor
is delivery of state-of-the-art broadband communication service
at a reasonable price. It must be state-of-the-art that is practical.
It cannot be soon-to-be state-of-the-art, as such technology is
often problematic.
Technology has high risks. We do not want to continually be taking
high risks. Therefore, in order to provide state-of-the-art service
we may decide to allow a private firm to provide the technology
and use our system to reach the customer. The important point is
using our fiber system to bring state-of-the-art communication services
to our customers.
Our price may be inherently low, unfortunately our service territory
is quite limited in terms of a communication company. We must work
with others. Since many applications in fiber are yet undeveloped
and are developing, it is important that we adopt our "one
key business" value as that of providing state-of-the-art
broadband communication services.
Emphasizing Doing What the Firm Knows
Best
Burbank Water and Power's strength is attention to reliability through
attention to technical issues. The Department works full time making
reliable connections to our electrical and water systems and taking
measures to ensure they operate at all times. This is done by simple
tree trimming to reduce tree caused outages to sophisticated insulation
testing of high voltage bushings.
These skills are done in a low profile manner. Like electrical
and water systems, a fiber communication system must be safe, protected,
and maintained. The links must be safe from animals, vandals and
accidents. The electronic equipment must be maintained and have
back-ups. When there are failures the problem must be corrected
and the failure examined carefully so the cause of the failure might
be eliminated and better controlled. Similar activities are undertaken
by our Water and Electric Divisions on a continuing basis.
Focused Yet Loose Controls
Tight controls over certain elements of the enterprise are vital.
For this business it is important that controls over the following
be carefully maintained.
- Dedicated fiber usage.
- Routes and expansion of routes.
- Station equipment.
- Rates.
- Interconnections with other communication companies.
Loose controls can be applied to:
- Customer equipment, provided it meets interoperability standards.
- Equipment maintenance.
- Applications using standard telephoning broadband fixed path
connections.
- D. Customer extensions done at customer expense.
These concerns requiring tight controls will be addressed by management
in a forthright manner. Loose controls means that records are maintained
and the equipment maintained are operated in a prudent and safe
manner, subject to strategic or budgetary control.
Competition and Growth
Our business is a unique market niche. Our objective is to provide
broadband communications in a relatively small geographic area in
conjunction with our electrical facilities. This is not the typical
corporate objective of a communication company. Usually, such a
company serves a much larger geographic area and increases in territory
over time. Our focus is on a specific set of customers in our community.
Therefore, we are not competition to the larger communication companies.
We can, in fact, feed them business. Our growth comes from the development
of broadband applications in Burbank. This growth comes from the
development of applications by others. To a degree this is something
like the development of our electrical grid. Our electric system
developed over time to provide power to appliances and equipment
our customers secured. In a similar manner, our broadband communication
system will develop over time to interconnect communication equipment
that our customers acquire.
Horizontal integration may be an effective strategic growth path.
Such growth would be implemented by providing a variety of communication
services. Such a variety is important to this plan. This strategy
allows us to use our resources in a more effective manner.
Vertical integration is not seen as an effective strategy from
our view point. Other firms may better serve these needs. Vertical
integration strategies could take our attention away from our focus
on the community and our customers.
Special Strategic Consideration
Connections to regional, state, national and international broadband
communication networks is very important for effective communications.
Burbank has some large companies who are very significant users
of national and international communications. Many communication
companies have fiber optics in Burbank. These fibers could be available
for local use by developing a fiber connection with these nearby
systems.
These networks are not to be confused with the National Information
Infrastructure Committee, otherwise known as the Information Highway.
The fiber networks located in Burbank are for telephone and specialized
broadband communications applications. Connections could be made
to the proposed Information Highway if it is available and applicable
for our uses.
This business plan follows the developing broadband communications
technology in conjunction with existing and developing communications
infrastructure and evolving markets. Applications such as regional
retail markets are probably beyond the practical limits of Burbank
Water and Power. Our applications will tend to be local.
FINANCIAL
PROJECTIONS FOR BWP FIBER OPTIC SYSTEM
This section outlines the financial projections. The section is
divided into four parts: Sales Forecast, Capital Requirements, and
Operating Results. Operating Results combine sales, operating expenses,
and capital requirements.
- SALES FORECAST
Sales are projected along the five major service offerings. There
may be other possible services, which may be added in the future.
The services considered are:
- Local Area Network integration
- Video Transmission
- Dark Fiber
- Production Review and Control
- Telephone PBX interconnection
- City and Utility Services
LAN Integration
The large studios have a number of local area networks (LAN)
utilizing nearly all popular network conventions. These networks
are located throughout the city and are generally not interconnected.
Where they are currently interconnected the costs can be high
and the performance limited to a fraction of the network's capability
because of the cost traditional telephone lines and services
and their slower speed.
The initial service offering will be for the integration of
these networks. These services are expected to use ten fibers
in the Media District and six fibers in the airport and downtown
areas. These initial services are expected to generate $5000
a month in sales. These services are expected to grow at a rate
of a new customer or connection every six weeks, or nine a year.
In 1996 these services would be transferred to a hub service
to make better use of available fiber capacity and make switch
services a possible service. By 1998/99 this service is projected
to generate $120,000 to $150,000 a year in revenues.
Video Transmission
This service could be offered through a reseller or may be developed
in conjunction with other systems such as Pacific Bell. It is
a product discussed quite frequently by those in the entertainment
industry. However, this is a new technology and it is in the
earliest stages of a product life cycle. Sales revenue for us
is expected to be marginal, but we should experience rapid growth
after 1996. No sales are anticipated in the first year. Sales
are expected in the second year to be $30,000. By the end of
1997 sales are expected to be $60,000 a year. Growth beyond
1997 is very dependent on our network capability and is difficult
to project.
Dark Fiber
Dark Fiber has several potential customers. We could easily
deploy this service using radial extensions from our main loops.
This would allow customers to use their own equipment to communicate
point to point.
Initial sales are expected to begin in the first year the service
offered. Sales by 1997 are expected to be $50,000. Growth should
be comparable to LAN integration with a new service every six
weeks. Some LAN integration could be done with Dark Fiber service.
Production Review and Control
This approach to remote editing uses less fiber spaces than
dark fiber so more signals can be sent per fiber. Because of
the need to review and control production throughout, it is
a likely candidate for joint services with other communication
companies such as Pacific Bell, AT&T, or Teleport. Because
of our lower communication channel costs, this market should
grow faster in our area than other areas. Initial revenue expected
from a few hookups in 1995/96, is expected to total $12,000.
Growth is very dependent on developing joint services with other
communication companies.
This application differs from dark fiber in that the service
providers must provide specialized equipment, service, and training
for the customer. Our role would be in linking such equipment
together using our system.
Telephone PBX Integration
This product has strong potential. In it's simplest form it
is likely to generate perhaps $15,000 to $25,000 a year in revenue.
The development of this market is very dependent on future developments.
City, School, and Utility Services
This sales segment is our largest customer. While the specifics
related to the design of the I-net system for the City will
not be known until the Sammon's franchise is finalized, an estimate
was developed based on very general requirements. Two fibers
were assumed to be required and no special lines or equipment
were considered. The utility services were priced at a $100,000
which is 40% lower than the annual costs of a dedicated utility
system.
The City I-net sales are estimated to be $25,000 per year.
This estimate is based on links to seven buildings. These buildings
are City Hall, Fire Station 12, Fire Station 15, Library-Ralph
Foy Park, Fire Training Center, Public Works Yard, and Water
Treatment Plant. These buildings were chosen as a representation
of the portion of I-net that would use City rather than Sammon's
facilities. Actual usage and buildings connected may vary.
Utility Service sales are projected at $100,000 a year. This
will provide the utility with a very reliable communication
network that will allow for data, voice, and specialized carriers
for power line protection. This is less than the cost of the
utility of providing a communication network for their exclusive
use.
Combined Sales Forecast
Combining these five products the following sales forecast can
be produced:
|
Combined Sales Forecast
|
| |
1995/96 |
1996/97 |
1997/98 |
1998/99 |
| |
|
|
|
|
| LAN Int. |
$30,000 |
$70,000 |
$100,000 |
$150,000 |
| Video |
0 |
30,000 |
60,000 |
60,000 |
| Dark Fiber |
12,000 |
24,000 |
50,000 |
50,000 |
| Production |
5,000 |
12,000 |
30,000 |
40,000 |
| Telephone |
3,000 |
7,500 |
15,000 |
20,000 |
| City Svc. |
$25,000 |
25,000 |
25,000 |
25,000 |
| Utl. Svc. |
$100,000 |
100,000 |
100,000 |
100,000 |
| |
------- |
------- |
------- |
------- |
| TOTALS |
$175,000 |
268,000 |
380,000 |
445,000 |
These forecasts will require an effective implementation in
order to be achieved.
- CAPITAL REQUIREMENTS
AND ANNUALIZED EXPENSES
The cost to install the initial loop is expected
to be about $900,000. This will provide 96 strands of fiber
and three hub OC-12 SONET network. An OC-12 network operates
at nearly 680 million bits per second and may carry as many
as 10,000 voice channels. This will link many of our electrical
facilities and integrate our SCADA and power plant operations.
It will also allow for improved data and telephone communications
between facilities.
The fiber optic cables have a life of 20 years.
The SONET equipment has a life of 10 years. The fiber optic
cable is expected to cost $425,000 installed. The SONET equipment
and installation will cost about $80,000 per hub, or $240,000
for three hubs. The specialized utility equipment will cost
about $250,000.
The total depreciation expense including specialized
utility equipment, is $70,250 per year. The cable and SONET
equipment needed for the system portion of this Initial system
is $45,250 per year. The specialized utility equipment for utility
needs are projected to have a depreciation expense of $25,000
per year.
Operating expenses are low for this equipment.
However, system reconfiguration, engineering, and management
can be significant. This will require approximately three employee
years in order to support this system. For estimating purposes
this plan projects three employees each at $60,000 per year
in salaries and $25,000 per year in overhead. An additional
$60,000 in salaries and $25,000 in overheads is assumed for
other departmental support. Actual salaries will be determined
upon detailed job analysis.
Outside professional and contracted services are
expected. These services will be estimated at $30,000 a year.
This will allow for the use of some outside help for special
problems or concerns that are not known. Travel and training
expenses are estimated at $10,000. These are also general estimates.
These expenses will be phased in as the system
grows. The following expenses are estimated:
|
Cash Expenses
|
| |
|
|
|
|
| |
1995/96 |
1996/97 |
1997/98 |
1998/99 |
| |
|
|
|
|
| Salaries |
$120,000 |
$170,000 |
$210,000 |
$240,000 |
| Benefits |
50,000 |
75,000 |
85,000 |
100,000 |
| Outside Services |
0 |
15,000 |
30,000 |
30,000 |
| Travel & Training |
5,000 |
8,000 |
10,000 |
10,000 |
| |
------- |
------- |
------- |
------- |
| TOTALS |
$175,000 |
$268,000 |
$335,000 |
$380,000 |
These expenses are for the initial system only.
It does not include any enhancements that are not discussed
specifically in this report. The initial system is composed
of a fiber optic cable, three SONET hubs, and connectors at
the major substation and offices of Burbank Water and Power.
- OPERATING RESULTS
Combining the revenues, depreciation and expenses the following
income statement can be estimated.
| |
Pro Forma Income Statement
for Communication System |
| |
|
|
|
|
| |
1995/96 |
1996/97 |
1997/98 |
1998/99 |
| |
|
|
|
|
| Revenue |
$175,000 |
$268,000 |
$380,000 |
$445,000 |
| Expenses |
$175,000 |
$268,000 |
$235,000 |
$380,000 |
| Depreciation |
$ 45,250 |
$ 45,250 |
$ 45,250 |
$ 45,250 |
| Cash Flow |
0 |
0 |
$45,000 |
$65,000 |
| |
-------- |
------- |
------- |
------- |
| Income |
-$45,250 |
-45,250 |
$250 |
$19,750 |
The operating results improve over time, as is the case with
many ventures, before becoming profitable.
IMPLEMENTATION OF
COMMUNICATION SERVICES
In order to make utility communication services available, Burbank
Water and Power must establish the necessary facilities, agreements,
rates, and procedures to operate effectively. Generally, the procedure
and policies will be those similar to that which are established
for water and power.
The City Attorney will review the regulatory requirements that
might govern municipal telephone or other utility communication
services. This review would not consider municipal cable TV operations.
Wireless utility communication services may be considered in the
future but will not be part of the initial system.
Burbank Water and Power will negotiate agreements with other communication
companies for mutual services. Pacific Bell and Teleport Communications
Groups have expressed interest in such services. These will be developed,
set in agreement form, and brought to the City Council for review
and approval.
Burbank Water and Power will develop network agreements with customers
who require linking a number of facilities in Burbank into one system.
These agreements will be brought to the City Council for review
and approval.
Burbank Water and Power will develop rates for communication services
and submit these rates to the City Council for approval. In addition,
Burbank Water and Power will develop fees for establishing service
and modifying existing services.
Burbank Water and Power will support the Information Services Division
in arranging for this incorporation of communication services billing
into the billing and accounting processes.
|